My Gorgeous Mistake
You may not have known this, but I loved someone once.
It was a self-conscious, desperate love. Not the version that makes you better, wiser, stronger. But the love that comes from needing someone terribly, and feeling whole, partly because of their understanding. It wasn't "in" love. It was sadder than that.
He never loved me in return, and if he did, it was simply as a result of my manipulations. It took me a year to realize that. In fact, I wasn't thinking clearly about anything at all for many months following our separating.
The dust had barely settled on our split before he began using the "ex girlfriend" phrase. He seemed so anxious to say it. I imagine it was because for the duration of our nine month relationship (off and on...off again, on again, etc) I had not allowed, as I have never allowed, for him to refer to me as his girlfriend. At first, he wanted desperately to use titles. But eventually, I assume, grew tired of asking, and accepted the inevitability that I would never budge. I would have been happy, in hindsight, to be considered the girlfriend, but was too busy testing him continuously to bother realizing it. But again, after the split, it was all I heard. It became, sort of, his term of endearment for me. I was his ex girlfriend, he was my gorgeous mistake. (From hence forth to be referred to as such...or in short, MGM.)
*I wish I could take credit for the phrase, as I find it to be incredibly befitting of all KINDS of situations in my life, but the kudos go to Sinead O'Connor, I Do Not Want What I Haven't Got, circa 1989. A master wordsman if you ask me.)
I forget at what point it became inevitable to us that we were over. We lived states apart, and relied heavily upon the quality of our hours long conversations to sustain the intrigue between visits. They had already begun to fade terribly by this time last year, and the wheels were in motion for my move to New York, though I barely knew it at the time. I don't believe that I ever REALLY thought I would lose him. He had become an inevitability in my life. I had connected more strongly, done more things more quickly, shown more sides more shamelessly of myself that I would never have presumed to be some day living without him. I know that sounds strange to say of someone with whom you never exchanged even the "L word"--but it was the truth of us. Or then...maybe it was my truth of us.
Irregardless, it came to a crashing halt last February. I moved to New York and we didn't speak for nearly two months. In mid April, I saw him again. And my world, which was spinning quite nicely in my new city and without him, came to a standstill. We spent only twenty-four hours together, but they were for me, the most genuine of the thousands of hours we'd spent before. They rekindled all of the crazy inside of me, and worse yet, re-established the million and one reasons we would, should, never be together. He left the next morning, and he kissed me goodbye in Penn Station. He had a girlfriend, I was dating a fantastic boy...both of which irrelevant. MGM had always kissed me when he said goodbye. Nothing about that had changed. And I never wanted it to.
I remember only three of our kisses, though there were countless. I remember the first two, because they changed everything. And I remember that last kiss, because it changed nothing. He got onto his train and I never saw him again.
The inevitability, as I have said, of the end of a terrible, albeit gorgeous mistake...is what makes it all so heartbreaking. There seems, in the end, to be some things over which we simply have no control. We lose, sometimes. Despite our greatest efforts.
The inspiration behind these thoughts, is that I will have to see him again, in just two weeks. He is in love now, and I too have moved along. But much like a recovering addict, when faced with the potential presence of your vice, one must consider the dangers. My mother today, who lived as much as she could through the MGM ordeal with me last year, kindly but in no uncertain terms told me to stay away from him by whatever means possible. "He is a terrible weakness for you, Jennifer." She sighed. She is absolutely right.
The lesson, I hope, that we glean from our mistakes (no matter how much fun they were to make) is that we can choose not to make them again.
I hope that is what I choose.